Paste your Google Webmaster Tools verification code here

Is Your Open Door Policy REALLY Open?

 

I was talking with a friend recently about some troubles she is having at work. She works for a larger company who promotes their “open door” policy – if an employee is having a hard time or needs guidance on handling work situations, they are encouraged to contact corporate to get the help they need.

 

Sometimes, while thinking the door is really open, it can be only partially open and jammed from the other side it seems.

 

As the story goes, there was an issue at work. My friend had a conversation with her direct manager and the issues went unresolved. After another attempt, she went to the store manager for help, again with the same result. Time passed, and, not quite sure what to do from here, remembered the company’s open door policy and wanted to try that route.

 

What happened next was interesting. She went to the company website to send a form (she prefers email and content put into writing) and found the information about the open door policy. It took a little digging, but she was able to find the area to submit her request. So far, so good.

 

The first step asked if she was an employee, customer, or other (not sure what other would be though). After choosing employee, there were three options: 1) I have an issue regarding my work and need help, 2) I have a concern with something that is happening at my location, and 3) I have a general employment question. When choosing the first option, she was met with a statement along the lines of “thank you for your concern. Please talk with your direct supervisor first. If that does not resolve your issue, please go to your store manager.” That was also the case for the second option. If someone selects the third option, they could continue completing the form.

 

Now, I completely get this; being a larger company, I’m sure they would get a myriad of requests that could likely be handled at a lower level. However, this can send the wrong message – had there been an additional line that said, “If you have already tried the above and still have concerns, please click here to continue” it would have been better.

 

Essentially, employees in a similar situation could walk away with the feeling that if they follow the proper channels with regard to chain of command, so to speak, and are still having problems, the company really doesn’t want to hear about it. That may or may not be true, but this is how it could be perceived.

 

Think about your company’s employee policy – is the door wide open, open just a bit, or jammed shut? Take a look at it from an employee’s perspective too, to make sure that you are making the process as simple as possible, while alleviating the need to handle issues that aren’t relevant at this level, but also to make sure you’re sending the right message to those employees who are having difficulties. This can go a long way in employee satisfaction and perception.

 

Share

No Survey For You!

 

I’m a fan of customer feedback surveys – when done correctly, companies can gain some very valuable feedback. Does your company have consistently glowing feedback, with little to no negativity? Before you pat yourself on the back, make sure the way customers are being invited to take the survey are truly collecting information that is not skewed in any way.

 

Below are a few real life examples that have surprised me to see, causing me to wonder what the data collection looks like on the back end.

 

1. “No survey for you!” – I was recently waiting in line to complete a transaction. I overheard the employee ask a guest several people ahead of me how they would rate his service. She replied, “good” and he asked for a number between one and ten, with ten being the highest. Awkward, right?

 

She says “I guess a ten. It was good” and I watched him print the receipt, circling the QR code at the bottom of the survey. He then encouraged her to take the survey and share her rating there.

 

Being in the industry I am, I was thankful that I had customers ahead of me to watch what happens next. The next three customers were asked the same question, and the process repeated – receipt, QR code circled, mentioned the survey.

 

The woman in front of me was having a bad day, and was not happy with the wait. When it came time to answer the question, she shared her displeasure with the wait and that there was not more help. He asked her to clarify with a number and she said, “Maybe a 4 or 5.”

 

Can you guess what happened next?

 

The employee printed the receipt, handed it to her, and wished her a good day. No circling on the receipt, no mention of the survey. I’m sure the QR code was there, but it wasn’t highlighted or mentioned in any way, maybe in hopes that this customer wouldn’t take it.

 

2. “I really need a raise” – another example is similar to the one above. While making a purchase at a retail store, the cashier ends the transaction by asking if I had a good experience. She then asks me to complete a survey and rate her high because the company is looking at the results and will be basing raises for the new year on the results. She writes her name on the receipt and asks me to give her a good review because “she really could use the extra money.”

 

3. “Please don’t tell me how I feel, or stretch the truth” – One cashier ended the transaction by circling the URL at the bottom of the receipt, explaining that if I give the company a 9 or 10 rating, I will entered into a monetary drawing.

 

Having shopped at this store for a long time, I know they’ve had the monetary drawing for a while now; adding the “rate us high and you’ll be entered” send a couple of wrong messages. One, they only want the high ratings, and two, the only way you could be entered is to give a high rating. So what if I give them a 5? Do they throw out my response? Or do they keep it but I don’t get a chance to win?

 

The best way to get the most accurate feedback is to make sure employees are encouraging customers to take the survey during each and every transaction. It’s good, in theory, to tie incentives to the results, but be careful of how that translates with your staff. As an additional measure, incorporate this type of information into your performance reviews or mystery shopping program – incorporate a question that asks if the employee mentioned the feedback survey, and if so, if it was handled objectively.

 

Feedback is great when collected correctly; make sure your invitations come with no strings attached!

 

 

Share

Marketing to The Teens? Vloggers Are The New Mommy Bloggers

 

Claire’s has found a great way to connect with their target demographic – teens. The company recently realized a decline in sales in this demographic, and realized that they needed a new approach.

 

Welcome to YouTube! Not only did they realize that this demographic spends a lot of time on the site, but they’ve gone a step further and connected with popular “YouTubers” or “vloggers” – these are internet sensations that have a massive teen following.

 

According to a recent article, Claire’s has partnered with AwesomenessTV as well as some internet celebrities to promote their brand. Below is an example of TheVamps, a popular group with 1.1 million followers, who did a book signing at a Chicago area Claire’s store:

 

 

 

To take it a step further, anyone visiting the Clarie’s YouTube page will see the “featured” channels, which feature accounts that are popular and fall in line with the demographic, further increasing their “cool” status.

claries

 

As a parent of a daughter in this age group, I can attest to the popularity of these groups. She is quite obsessed with a group of young men and women whose main career seems to be posting videos, writing books, and other seemingly simple activities. Some are most known for playing Minecraft, a popular game among this demographic, and videotaping themselves playing along with running commentary. To me, this seems like a silly thing, but among this demographic, it’s gold. As I learned more from my daughter, I realized the reach of these individuals, and Clarie’s (and other companies), have been smart to partner with them. With the sheer number of subscribers and devoted ones at that, this is by far the best means to reach the masses in this demographic while instilling the “cool” factor into the brand.

 

There is another one I’ve gotten wind of, mainly through my own teen demographic experience:

 

Pizza Hut has partnered with CaptainSparklez, a popular vlogger with 8.6 million subscribers. Fans can purchase a “CaptainSparklez” Pizza as part of a promotion.

 

sparklez

 

 

Vloggers are akin to the “Mommy Bloggers” back in the day – their influence is wide and powerful. What may seem silly to us adults is some serious business to this demographic, and marketers should pay attention. Claire’s made a smart move here; it’s a good marketing move, and one that others should take note of.

Share